Comment: Blueprint to cope with crises ( 2004-02-03 23:56) (China Daily)
In the draft constitutional
amendments that passed preliminary review by the Standing Committee of the
National People's Congress (NPC) last month, one term is worth noting: state of
emergency.
If approved by the full session of NPC, the country's legislature, in March,
the term "state of emergency'' will be written into the Constitution. But there
is presently no explicit definition of the term in Chinese law.
Experts are working to outline a draft of emergency law and fill in that
blank.
Though its formal title is still to be decided, the law will certainly become
the country's first legal text outlining a specific explanation of the term and
stipulating the rights and responsibility of government, business and
individuals and other related issues in a case of emergency.
"The outbreak of SARS (severe acute respiratory syndrome) last spring served
as a warning to the country about the importance of crisis management,'' said
Xue Lan, a professor with the School of Public Policy and Management of Tsinghua
University.
The alert made many people realize our society lacks the experience and
mechanism to deal with emergencies like a public health crisis, terrorist
attacks or large scale natural disasters.
As reforms deepen, different groups see a reallocation of resources and
interests, producing seeds of instability.
Like all societies, ours has had its own way of dealing with emergencies. But
it also has problems that may endanger future efficiency, Peng Zongchao, a
colleague of Xue's, pointed out.
Measures against urgent occasions are often taken after problems occur. No
high-level arrangements or prior strategies are in place as precautions.
Different government offices are in charge of different kinds of emergencies,
and communication between those offices is often inadequate. There are no
government organs or consultation mechanisms that could control the situation as
a whole.
In most instances the government handles crises on its own rather than
involving resources and support from people across the country.
To some extent, the successful fight against SARS offers convincing proof of
Peng's points. After a high-profile committee was put in command, co-ordinating
different government offices and mobilizing the public to take part in
prevention and control efforts, the epidemic was rebuffed.
Now that a nation-wide mechanism to report and treat SARS is in place, the
disease is not nearly the national threat it was a year ago.
China has already had several laws involving emergency preparedness, for such
things as natural disasters, war and riots. But there is no fundamental
legislation outlining a national policy to deal with emergencies.
The law under discussion will fill that need.
Besides defining a "state of emergency'' and laying a legal basis for a
national system to deal with emergent issues, the law will stipulate the roles
of government, business and ordinary people.
Jiang Mingan, a professor with the School of Law of Peking University, said
the state of emergency is actually an "abnormal'' state of society versus its
"normal'' state.
When something unusual and dangerous happens, the government must motivate
all resources to ease the shock, prevent it from worsening, alleviate the damage
and so on. It will definitely need some extra special power.
The law of emergency will define the government's tasks in tackling the
crises and the extra power it will have during the period. At the same time, the
law will also draw a line of individual rights, which the State cannot surpass.
Just as Yu An, a professor of law in the same school with Xue and Peng,
observed, the practice of putting people under quarantine was over-stressed by
some localities during the SARS outbreak, and came close to violating individual
rights.
"The law will set out a legal framework for the government and individuals
about their responsibilities and rights. With such a framework, they will be
better able to enjoy their constitutional rights,'' Yu said.
Gu Linsheng, a researcher with the Development Research Academy for 21st
Century affiliated with Tsinghua University, stressed the importance enlisting
businesses in dealing with emergencies.
With the help of the business sector, equipment and materials needed in
emergent issues can be quickly produced and delivered. And businesses can offer
proper training to their employees on a daily basis, helping them better prepare
for emergencies as individual citizens.
The law will also have clauses about information gathering and release,
limits on transportation and communication, everyday education and training for
citizens and judicial practices during the state of emergency.
