It's high time tax reform started By Gao Peiyong (China Daily) Updated: 2005-03-07 09:40
[The author Gao Peiyong is a researcher at the Institute of Finance and Trade
Economics, Chinese Academy of Social Sciences.]
The principles of the new round of reform of the taxation system, which has
been under discussion for quite some time, were outlined in the Decision of the
Central Committee of the Communist Party of China on Issues Regarding the
Improvement of the Socialist Market Economic System, which was issued at the
third plenary session of the 16th Communist Party of China Central Committee in
October 2003.
The necessity and importance of such a reform are well-known in the country,
in businesses, academia and government departments. They all have high hopes for
the reform.
However, the reform has not been initiated except for the changes in
procedures for rebating taxes on exported products.
To sum up, the major obstacles for launching the reform are concerns over two
prospects. First, there are concerns that the tax reform would cause a large
reduction in tax revenue. Second, some people are worried that the already
overheated investment in fixed assets would be further boosted by the tax
reduction.
Therefore, easing these concerns is the key to initiating the tax reform.
Admittedly, the tax reform would cut down revenue. To be specific, the reform
measures on value-added tax and enterprise income tax would involve a reduction
to as much as 200 billion yuan (US$24.1 billion).
When the State coffers are far from full enough to support all the needs
calling for government input, it is natural for the authorities to remain
prudent on the tax reform.
Yet, suspending the tax reform solely because of the fear of tax income
reduction cannot be a solution to the problems waiting to be addressed.
Reform may never be initiated if we wait until State income from taxes rises
enough to withstand a reduction.
By examining fiscal income and expenditure in the last 10 years, it is easy
to see two inter-related tendencies.
Fiscal income has been on a continual rise since 1994 and the annual growth
rate is also higher each year.
The breakneck rise lasting for a decade has put total fiscal income at an
unprecedented level. The tax income in 2003 was 4.7 times that of 1993.
With the support of swelling tax income, fiscal expenditure expanded with an
even stronger momentum during the same period. Fiscal expenditure in 2003 was
5.7 times that of 1993.
In other words, the growth in tax income has been directly translated into
the boom of fiscal expenditure.
The net increase in total tax income in 2004 was 525.6 billion yuan (US$63.3
billion), which is at least 300 billion yuan (US$36.1 billion) more than
predicted.
If no special arrangements are made, the huge swell will directly lead to
similar growth in fiscal expenditure.
Once that happens, fiscal expenditure will be further boosted. Expenditure by
government departments at all levels would also grow accordingly, which makes
consolidating fiscal expenditure in the future a more challenging task.
As a matter of fact, tax income growth has reached its climax and will soon
follow a downward curve.
We have always seen the speedy growth in tax income attributed to economic
growth, policy adjustment and enhancement in tax collection.
The elevated tax income growth in 2004 is mainly driven by the following
three factors economic growth, price hikes and enhancement of tax collection.
However, no matter what the specific factors are for the three pillars of tax
income growth, economic growth is the only factor that could be relied upon in
the long term.
According to the estimate of the State Administration of Taxation, the taxes
actually collected have reached 70 per cent of all payable taxes by enhancing
tax collection. The proportion was only 50 per cent before 1994.
As the proportion goes up, it will be increasingly difficult to further boost
it.
Since the inflated tax income growth would cause the swell of fiscal
expenditure while the tax reform could cut down tax income, it is better to use
increased taxes to launch tax reform when tax income is booming.
It is easy to see that tax reform, which will reduce taxes, would definitely
provoke investment.
However, when the background of rocketing tax income growth is considered,
the conclusion could be different.
As mentioned previously, the larger than usual tax income growth will result
in the equally increased rise in fiscal expenditure and even stimulate the
impulse for investment in fixed assets from the government departments which
have been hushed by the central government for a while.
Although tax reduction would result in the expansion of investment, the
expansion is unlikely to be bigger than that caused by the swell in fiscal
expenditure.
Compared with the increase in fiscal expenditure and its provocative role in
stimulating fixed assets investment, the potential negative effects of tax
reform become much less significant.
On top of that, tax reform could consolidate the taxation system, which is a
final goal for us.
Looking at economic reform during the last 26 years, it is easy to see that
tax reform always plays a pioneering role.
The tax reduction at the early stage of the reform helped launch economic
reform. The tax reform in 1994 also paved the way for further innovations in
economic and fiscal systems.
Given the special position of tax reform in China's history, it is natural
that it should lead off a new round of economic reform.